Order Local is a pickup-first ordering page for small local food makers: 0% commission, plans from $0 to $39 a month, and payments that land in your own Stripe account. Square Online is a full e-commerce and point-of-sale platform built around shipping and in-person retail. Pick Square if you need a register, hardware, and inventory synced across channels.
Square Online details reflect our research as of July 2026
| Feature | Order Local | Square Online |
|---|---|---|
| Commission per sale | 0%. We take no per-order cut on any plan. | Square's per-sale cost is its processing rate — around 2.6% + $0.10 per transaction as of July 2026 — charged on top of the monthly plan. |
| Monthly cost | $0 Starter (5 items), $9 Growth (20 items), $19 Market (40 items, Advanced Analytics included), $39 Pro (unlimited items, every add-on). Add-ons are $9/month each. Annual billing is 2 months free. | Roughly $29–$79 a month for the comparable paid plans, as of July 2026. |
| Who pays processing | You do — Stripe's standard 2.9% + $0.30 comes out of each payment, and the payment goes into your own Stripe account. Order Local never holds your funds. | You do — Square's processing rate is deducted from each sale. Nothing is added to the customer's total. |
| Local pickup scheduling | The center of the product: pickup locations with their own hours, pickup windows, cutoff times, per-item lead times, and per-day capacity limits. | Available, but secondary. Square Online is a general e-commerce builder designed shipping-first, with pickup as one fulfillment option alongside it. |
| Payment options | Card through your own Stripe account, or Venmo — customers pay your @handle and you confirm each payment. | Square's own payment stack — that is the core of Square's business. |
| Catalog limits | 5 items on Starter, 20 on Growth, 40 on Market, unlimited on Pro. | Built for larger catalogs kept in sync across in-person and online channels. |
| Setup time | One sitting: add your items, add a pickup spot with its hours, connect Stripe, share the link. | A full online store builder — catalog, shipping, and channel settings to configure before you launch. |
| Best-fit customer | A one-person or small local food business selling by pickup — bakers, growers, makers, roasters, food trucks. | A business with a physical register, card hardware, and stock to keep in sync across in-person and online sales. |
Scroll the table sideways to see both columns.
Square figures reflect our research as of July 2026 — check Square's site for current pricing. "Setup time" describes scope, not a benchmark we ran.
Square is a bigger product than Order Local, and for several jobs it is simply the right tool. If any of these describe you, use Square.
Square sells point-of-sale hardware and runs the in-person side of a business. Order Local is not a POS, does not sell hardware, and does not replace your register.
Square Online is built shipping-first. Order Local is pickup-first and has no shipping labels, shipping rates, or delivery dispatch at all.
Square keeps one stock count across in-person sales and online. Order Local's limits are per-item, per-day caps for pickup — not multi-channel inventory.
Square Online is a full e-commerce site builder. Order Local is a focused ordering page for local pickup, not a website replacement.
If your business is pickup, and the volume goes through one pair of hands, the trade-offs run the other way.
Order Local takes no per-order cut on any plan, and the Starter plan is free for 5 catalog items with no credit card. The comparable Square paid plans start around $29 a month as of July 2026.
Payments go through your Stripe account, not ours — Order Local never holds your funds. You pay Stripe's standard 2.9% + $0.30 and nothing else per order.
Pickup locations with their own hours, bookable pickup windows, cutoff times in minutes, per-item lead times in days, and per-day capacity caps. Not a fulfillment checkbox on a shipping platform.
Turn Venmo on and customers can pay your @handle, with the order still tracked in your dashboard and you confirming each payment. Card orders keep running through Stripe alongside it.
Most vendors do not switch off Square entirely — they keep the register and move the pickup pre-orders. Both can run side by side.
Add your items with photos, prices, and modifiers. On Growth and up you can import a catalog by CSV or pull it from Stripe instead of typing it out.
Name each spot, set its hours and timezone, add a minimum notice in minutes, and set per-item lead times and daily caps.
Connect your own Stripe account, then point your Instagram bio, Google Business Profile, and QR codes at the new ordering link. Keep Square running for in-person and shipping if you need it.
Keep 100% of your sales. Pay only Stripe's standard processing fee.
Starter
Free for 5 items — try pickup ordering before you pay anything.
Growth
Room for a real lineup at 20 items, with catalog import.
Market
For a shop that wants to see what actually sells.
Pro
Unlimited items and every add-on included.
Not sure? Start free on our Starter plan — up to 5 items, no credit card required.
Set up your local ordering page today. Free to start, no credit card required.
Start for free